Thursday, December 25, 2025

PROJECT PROPOSAL: The Hunza Land Stewardship Initiative (HLSI) - LAND BANKING

 This proposal is designed to be presented as a heritage preservation strategy. Listen to what our Imam said in his Speech at the TMS Meeting at Baltit Fort, 25.9.96:

There are two ways of working, one with one's head only, and the other is to work with one's head and one's heart.”

I. Mission Statement


The mission of the HLSI is to protect the ancestral lands of the Hunza Valley from unplanned commercialization, ensure the preservation of agricultural livelihoods, and provide equitable access to land for housing and local entrepreneurship through permanent community stewardship.


PROJECT PROPOSAL: The Hunza Land Stewardship Initiative (HLSI)

To: [TMS;s/ Regional/Local Councils / GB Government Department]

From: Hunza Development Forum


Subject: Proposal for a Community-Led Land Bank and Trust to Manage Sustainable Growth in Hunza.

1. Executive Summary

Hunza is experiencing an unprecedented surge in tourism and infrastructure development. While this brings economic opportunity, it also leads to:

 * Loss of Agricultural Land: Orchards are being converted into concrete hotels.

 * Land Speculation: Rising prices are making land unaffordable for local youth.

 * Unplanned Growth: Construction is happening without proper sewage, water, or aesthetic planning.

The HLSI proposes the establishment of a Community Land Bank to acquire, hold, and lease land strategically, ensuring that Hunza’s development remains in the hands of its people while protecting its natural beauty.

2. Objectives

 * Prevent Fragmented Development: Consolidate small plots to allow for master-planned infrastructure.

 * Ensure Permanent Local Ownership: Use long-term leases instead of outright sales to prevent "land grabbing" by outside investors.

 * Preserve Food Security: Protect the "Green Belts" and traditional irrigation (Kuhls) from encroachment.

 * Generate Local Revenue: Create a self-sustaining fund for village-level social services (education/healthcare).

3. The Proposed Model: "The Green Lease"

Instead of the current model where land is sold and control is lost forever, the HLSI will operate as follows:

 * Land Pooling: Residents "deposit" their land into the Bank.

 * Unified Planning: The Bank creates a professional master plan (identifying where the road, sewage, and trees will go).

 * Equitable Returns: If a hotel is built on a portion of the banked land, the profits/rent are shared among all community members who pooled their land, even if the hotel isn't on their specific original plot.

4. Implementation Phases

Phase I: The Pilot Mapping (Months 1–4)

 * Identify a target area (e.g., a specific "Mohallah" or village section).

 * Conduct a GIS Digital Map of ownership, water channels, and soil fertility.

 * Hold "Jirgas" (community meetings) to build trust and explain the "Lease vs. Sale" benefit.

Phase II: Legal & Institutional Setup (Months 5–8)

 * Register the Land Trust as a legal entity under the GB Trust Act.

 * Form a Board of Directors (LSO members, women’s organization reps, and technical experts).

 * Draft the Standard Ground Lease Agreement.

Phase III: The "Bank" Opening (Months 9–12)

 * Acquisition of the first communal or donated plots.

 * Call for "Sustainable Development Proposals" (e.g., eco-lodges, community centers).

5. Expected Outcomes

| For the Government | For the Local Resident | For the Environment |

| Easier infrastructure rollout (roads/electricity). | Guaranteed long-term income from leases. | Zero construction on fertile orchard land. |

| Controlled, taxable commercial growth. | Retained ownership for future generations. | Modernized waste/water management. |

6. Resource Requirements

 * Technical: GIS mapping experts and urban planners. Alternately use the data compiled by AKCSP.

 * Legal: Experts in GB land revenue laws.

 * Financial: Initial seed funding for "Right of First Refusal" purchases (could be sourced from government grants or international climate funds).

7. Conclusion

The current trend of selling land for one-time payments is a "short-term gain for a long-term loss." By establishing a Land Bank, Hunza can transition from accidental development to intentional growth, ensuring that the valley remains prosperous, green, and owned by its descendants.


8. EXAMPLES:
Baltit: KHANDA/MALIKAMO SHIKARI - by DDO (Diramiting Development Organization); CLUSTER HOUSING - DALDAS; ALTI SAT - by TMS (proposed)
Galmit: Payagah by TMS
Garnish: DONG-E-DAS - by TMS (proposed)
Aliabad: TALTAQ DAS

Concept:

Land banking is a strategic real estate and planning tool where an entity (government, community, or private developer) acquires and holds land for future use or development.


In a sensitive and unique region like Hunza, land banking can serve as a shield against unplanned commercialization while ensuring that the benefits of development remain within the local community.

1. What is Land Banking?

There are two primary ways to look at land banking, and they have very different goals:

 * Public/Community Land Banking: A "Land Bank" is a non-profit or governmental entity that acquires vacant, abandoned, or underutilized land to repurpose it for community needs like affordable housing, parks, or public infrastructure. Its goal is stabilization and community benefit.

 * Private/Investment Land Banking: Developers buy large tracts of undeveloped land in the path of anticipated growth. They hold it until the value increases or until they get "entitlements" (permissions) to build. Its goal is profit.

2. Implementation in Hunza: The Context

Hunza faces unique challenges: extreme topography, scarce agricultural land, and a sudden surge in tourism-driven development. Implementing land banking here requires a Community-First Model.

A. Historically, much of the land in Hunza was Communal Land

. Recent legal reforms (around 2025) have started shifting this land back to communal ownership. A community land bank could manage these "new" communal lands to prevent them from being sold off piece-meal to outside speculators.

B. Strategic "Land Readjustment"

Because the terrain is mountainous, land is often fragmented into small terraces.

 * How it works: Multiple small landowners "pool" their land into a single "bank."

 * The Benefit: The community can plan a proper road, drainage, and utility system for the whole area rather than each person building a hotel that blocks their neighbor’s view or water access.

C. Preservation of Agricultural Identity

Hunza’s food security depends on its orchards. A land bank can be used to:

 * Freeze Development: Buy development rights from farmers so they get paid the "real estate value" of their land but are legally required to keep it as an orchard forever.

 * Zoning Control: The land bank ensures that hotels are built only on non-arable rocky patches, saving the fertile soil.

RELATED:

Karakoram in Transition: Culture, Development and Ecology in the Hunza Valley

Saturday, December 13, 2025

Grade Assessment of Hunza Development Forum Blog

 The Hunza Development Forum blog appears to be a focused and niche platform dedicated to sustainable development, knowledge sharing, and community empowerment, primarily centered on the Gilgit-Baltistan region of Pakistan, with a special emphasis on Hunza.

Here is an assessment of its grade and comparison to other development blogs:

🌟 

Based on the content and its stated mission, the Hunza Development Forum blog can be graded as Highly Relevant and Valuable within its specific niche.

 * Focus and Specificity: Excellent. It zeroes in on the local development challenges and initiatives of Hunza/Gilgit-Baltistan (e.g., climate change, landslides, customary laws, cultural preservation, and the role of the Aga Khan Trust for Culture). This high degree of specificity is its major strength, as it fills a gap that larger, more general blogs often overlook.

 * Content Depth: Good to Excellent. It hosts in-depth articles on complex topics like "Civilizational Erasure," "Climate Change & Glacial Melting," and analyses of development models, often featuring contributions from local and foreign experts, academics, and practitioners.

 * Target Audience: Very Strong. It is clearly aimed at local community members, policymakers, researchers, and international development professionals interested in the region.

 * Frequency/Recency: The search results indicate relatively recent posts (e.g., December 2025, November 2025, September 2025), suggesting it is an active platform.

 * Credibility: The inclusion of named contributors and references to research/archival work suggests a focus on informed, credible content.

⚖️ Comparison to Other Development Blogs

When compared to broader development blogs, the Hunza Development Forum blog differs significantly in scope and influence:

| Feature | Hunza Development Forum Blog | Major Development Blogs (e.g., ADB, World Bank, PIDE) |

|---|---|---|

| Scope | Niche/Regional. Focuses on one specific area (Hunza/Gilgit-Baltistan) and its localized issues. | Global/National. Covers development issues across Asia and the Pacific, or at a national/macro level for a country like Pakistan. |

| Topics | Highly specific: local governance, cultural heritage, micro-level environmental issues (glacier melting, landslides), regional history. | Broad: Macro-economics, poverty reduction, national policy reforms, health financing, SDGs, large-scale infrastructure, national education. |

| Contributors | A mix of local scholars, practitioners, and regional experts (e.g., Hisamullah Beg, Saadia Beg). | Often features staff economists, senior researchers, and high-level officials from the respective international/national organizations. |

| Impact/Reach | High impact within its specific community of interest (Gilgit-Baltistan focus) but smaller global reach. | Very Large global or national reach, influencing major policy decisions and academic discourse. |

| Tone/Style | Often academic, interdisciplinary, and focused on on-the-ground realities and history. | Typically policy-oriented, data-heavy, and focused on large-scale systemic solutions. |

💡 Conclusion

The Hunza Development Forum blog is not comparable to global powerhouses like the World Bank or Asian Development Bank blogs in terms of macro-level influence or sheer readership.

However, for someone seeking deep, specific, and culturally-informed insights into the development challenges and solutions in the remote, mountainous region of Hunza/Gilgit-Baltistan, it is a superior and more relevant resource than a general development blog.

Its "grade" is excellent for its specific purpose, though its "reach" is smaller than general development blogs.

Would you like me to look for a specific post or topic on the Hunza Development Forum blog, or perhaps summarize one of the other major development blogs for you?


Monday, December 8, 2025

Civilizational Erasure

The term "civilization erasure" has recently gained prominence due to its use in the United States' 2025 National Security Strategy document, released by the Trump administration. The phrase is also used in academic and philosophical discussions about historical and cultural preservation, colonialism, and potential future societal collapse.

In the 2025 U.S. National Security Strategy

The phrase "civilizational erasure" appears in the November/December 2025 National Security Strategy document, primarily in the context of Europe. Context: The document argues that mass migration, declining birth rates, and "anti-democratic" policies in Europe could lead to its "civilizational erasure" within 20 years.

Reception: The claim has been met with significant criticism from European officials and political experts, who have described the language as echoing far-right conspiracy theories such as the "great replacement theory".

Political Implications: The strategy document suggests that some European countries may not be "reliable allies" in the future if these trends continue, marking a shift in U.S. foreign policy rhetoric.

In Academic and Other "Papers"

Outside of the political context, the concept of "civilization erasure" or the "erasure of civilization" appears in academic literature across various fields: Colonialism and Epistemic Erasure: Several papers discuss how colonial forces have historically attempted to erase indigenous cultures, languages, and knowledge systems by imposing their own epistemologies and power structures.

Historical and Cultural Preservation: Research in late antiquity and archaeology examines the physical and cultural erasure of past societies, using practices like damnatio memoriae (condemnation of memory) and the destruction of monuments as a means of political and religious change.

Philosophical and Futuristic Scenarios: The term is also used in philosophical and scientific discussions regarding the potential end of modern civilization due to environmental collapse (climate change, resource depletion) or the development of advanced artificial intelligence (ASI). The novel The Road by Cormac McCarthy is often cited in literary analyses that explore themes of loss and the erasure of civilization.